My discussion on the issue: Living together in Myanmar context and prenuptial agreement.
My discussion on the issue: Living together in Myanmar
context and prenuptial agreement.
If we ask Myanmar people that ‘can you accept living
together?’, most of the people will answer that they can’t. It’s not a
surprise. Especially older people, parents and religious people will not agree
absolutely. In Burmese (include all ethnic group) concept and culture, they
think that talking about sex in public or school is not a good thing and
shameful thing. There is not much awareness of sex. Parents don’t share about
it and, they think that it’s no need to share and, young men will know by
themselves. It’s not match with culture and religion .However living together
before marriage can give us good things and also make bad ones. One thing, we
have to think more serious that living together is a strong flow in
globalization and, we can’t ban it.
Firstly I want to discuss Living together before marriage
with positive view. By living together before marriage, we can see well she/he
is worth to marry or not. Because of living together before marriage, we can
understand well our partner’s personality, character, behavior, thinking/idea
and moods. We can see that whether we can match to each other in sex, whether
we can negotiate with our partner, if we get married actually. It’s very
important when we decide to marry. If we don’t know well a bout each other and
get married, we can face many problems that we can’t negotiate, character and
also sex (many couples separate and spouses do commit adultery because they
can’t give satisfactions to each other in sex - bad in bed. Dr. Khin Mang Ngio
stated that case in his book and also Health Digest Journal always state how
sex is important in Happy Family life). So most of the couple was??? to divorce
after marriage. I think that divorce before marriage is better than divorce
after marriage.
I would like to review some effects of
living together. But we can see cons of living together before marriage. Living
together makes the lack of trust and loyalty of couple. If it’s over, the
number of abortion may be higher more than before. In the article,
“Cohabitation or Marriage?” of Rev Declan Flanagan and Dr ES Williams,
they have stated that ‘ In UK, the
proportion of women reporting an abortion in the last five years is least
common among the widowed (1.2%) and married (2.6%); single women reported
higher rates (7.3%), but the highest rates were among cohabiting women (10.2%).’
According to this survey, it was obvious that the number of
abortion is highest rates were among cohabiting women.
The effect of it is that some
conflict of social, culture and religious more appear. Dr. Helen Watt has mentioned that, what
has happened to society, more than three decades after the passing of the
Abortion Act in Britain. He stated that ‘Society has not become more welcoming of children, or more celebratory
of pregnancy. In the same way, men have been encouraged to back away from their
responsibilities for their partners and their children. Medicine has not become
more respectful of human life. Instead of serving the health of their patients,
and supporting those who cannot be cured, doctors increasingly see themselves
as mere technicians serving patients’ desires. With the coming of legal abortion,
thousands of children have lost their lives at the hands of such doctors. Every
abortion is a human tragedy for the child and for its mother. No child can be
‘replaced’ by a child born later. Every child is an individual, with its own
future to respect.
I think that most of modern
young people may accept. Nowadays we can see that culture gradually appear,
especially urban like Yangon, Mandalay. This culture come from western and
gradually influences some Asian countries especially develop country because of
a globalization flow. Last Saturday night, in Falam Youth Talk, a female
student who attends university in Japan, shared us about the situation of
living together in Japan us. In also Myanmar, the government makes
political change on the road way to democracy and use opened economics system.
And citizens ask more Human Rights. We can say that the wave of globalization
will strike our country more. So the culture of living together from western will
gradually mix to Myanmar culture . If Myanmar economics is opened and trade
with international corporations especially from EU and US and, foreign business
more invest .There will be probably culture shock. Even though most of people
can’t accept, we can’t ban absolutely that wave. So I think that we should
think how to use effectively in Myanmar society.
Now, I would like to analyze another issue, prenuptial
agreement, especially advantages and disadvantages. What can be the consequences?
Let us consider whether we need it.
Why we may need? Nick Fagan have stated some advantages of a prenuptial agreement. He said that, when a couple decides to marry, they have many decisions to make relate with the property, assets, business matter, protecting their children and money. Prenuptial agreements clear everything up before the individuals get married. And, many couples used to say is how property will be divided in the event of divorce or death. Even if a divorce does occur, the prenuptial agreement may avoid litigation for the parties and, it is already determined clearly where the property, assets and money go. Since these issues will already have been decided in the agreement. Prenuptial agreements can sure that heirlooms and other property of your own family.
Moreover, by referring to protecting
children, when we sign a prenuptial agreement, we can ensure that our children
(if we have - may be from first marriage) receive your
belongings to, the assets and money, and we want them to have in the
event that you die before your spouse. Moreover,
prenuptial agreement may help to protect an inheritance to a child from an
earlier marriage. (if we wish..)
If you’re a partner of a business, a prenuptial agreement
can protect your interests in the case of your death. For instance, it can help
you by stating that your spouse will claims for any part of the business after
your death. In addition to we can also indicate that she is considered a
"shareholder" of your partner of the business.
Let us discuss some disadvantages. There are
also some disadvantages to have a prenuptial agreement. We may be discomfort to
each other in talking issues of divorce before the marriage. We can say that
there is no guarantee a court will upheld the agreement. Also, even if an
agreement is kept, there's no assurance the entire agreement will be up held. We
can see that there are a lot of corruptions behind court over Myanmar. There is
no justice litigation in our country that even the couples divorce in court;
husband or spouse usually win by bribing to the judge. What is more, it can
make the individual of couples less trust. It’s not romantic.
In Myanmar, should we use prenuptial
agreement? My envisage is
if there are the high number of consequences and affect of
divorce_ also not divorces _in our society, it is the sign that we should use. Because
many people fear the cost and emotional impact of
litigation in Court. For me,
there is no reason I can’t accept, and also I hope most of people will
gradually accept on the religious, culture point of view because it’s not as a heavy
issue as living together. However, I worry as prenuptial agreement, can we
consider that the value, dignity and character of family is not serious minor? If
people consider whether to have a prenuptial or postnuptial agreement, they
should ask legal advice in local lawyer.
If possible, I love romantic and want to
belong Happy Family, and I want to stay faithfully and freely each other forever.
Submitted to T. Denial
By Thang Mawi
References;
Advantages Of A Prenuptial Agreement, December 2, 2005, By Nick Fagan
Cohabitation or Marriage?, By Rev Declan Flanagan
and Dr ES Williams
Living
Together: Pregnancy and Parenthood, By Dr. Helen Watt
http://www.livingtogether.com
http://www.ezinearticles.com
http://www.divorcenet.com
http://www.ehow.com
http://www.nolo.com
